The Football Ramble, because football is permanent
Last updated: 11 minutes ago

Latest football news – BBC Sport

« »

England need to cure their Talisman Syndrome

Luke Moore | 14 October 2011

By lashing out and earning himself a three game ban, has Wayne Rooney given England an opportunity to succeed at international level?
England need to cure their Talisman Syndrome

talisman (noun, pl. -mans) - Anything thought to have magical or protective powers

Fifty-four minutes gone, and the substitutes’ board appears. He looks up, sees his number and slowly but purposefully strides toward the touchline. The burden of carrying a nation weighing heavily on his shoulders, he removes the captain’s armband and takes his place on the bench.

This battle is lost, he knows. Despite the score locked at 1-1, Spain are on their way home; France are much stronger, the powerhouse midfielder Patrick Vieira is driving them forward again and the genius of Zinedine Zidane, aided and abetted by Florent Malouda, Franck Ribery (who has already scored a sublime equaliser) and Thierry Henry will eventually see them run out 3-1 winners, the mercurial Zidane exquisitely placing a cherry on top in injury time by cutting inside Puyol and skewering the ball into the Spanish net right through the middle of their hearts.

With that deft move, Spain’s hopes are crushed, and so is Raúl’s 100-odd cap international career.

Spain were cured of Talisman Syndrome by the passing of time. They never really set about looking for a cure. Instead, a man and captain who had so often been appealed to for something, anything to make the difference at a crucial time in a crucial game was suddenly no longer available to them.

Whilst a 3-2 defeat to Northern Ireland in Belfast was no way for a man of such immense quality to end his international career, it was the trigger event which caused Spain to sit up and realise that there was life after their all-time top scorer and captain, and they had the good sense to not only not look for a replacement, but to resist recalling him when his form for Real Madrid made him difficult to ignore.

Instead, they harnessed the collective spirit and ability of their squad to work and play as a unit, allowed Fernando Torres and David Villa to grow and evolve upfront and their stunningly inventive midfield to pull strings as they’d never been pulled before.

In that same tournament, in the same round, and very nearly in the same minute of the game, another Talisman was also exiting the field, but in a more explosive manner. This was the first (but, as we saw last week, not the last) example of Wayne Rooney’s fragile temperament. His unnecessary stamp on Ricardo Carvalho left the referee no option but to produce the red card.

In actual fact, Wayne Rooney wasn’t quite a fully-fledged Talisman by that point. The baton of crushing expectation hadn’t fully completed its journey because the other half still had the fingers of David Beckham wrapped fairly tightly around it. But as sure as night follows day, the sun would eventually set on Beckham’s international career, just as it had on Paul Gascoigne’s before him, and Rooney was always destined to have the albatross with a red St. George’s cross crassly painted on it hung around his neck by the media, the public and, most criminally of all, his teammates.

Elsewhere, Italy, the eventual winners of that World Cup in 2006, had recently had a Talisman Syndrome of their own to contend with. It had been touch and go whether Francesco Totti would appear in the tournament at all due to a metatarsal injury, and the general public were sent white with worry over how they would perform without the jewel in their crown.

Il Gladiatore had inherited his millstone from Alessandro Del Piero of course, who’d taken up the mantle from the universally-loved Roby Baggio before him, and Italy were stuck in a mire, constantly looking towards their Talisman for inspiration.

Then along came Lippi, who paid particular attention to the togetherness of his squad, and Totti was asked to play more of a team role. He acquiesced, put his attitude and role at the mercy of his teammates, and their Talisman Syndrome was cured. Marcelo Lippi had coached the entire country out of it, and the Italians were victorious.

Back in Blighty, Rooney clearly suffers from the pressure that international football bestows upon him. A young man that uses aggression to fuel his clear and remarkable talent, he simply has to play on the very edge of his wits to perform at the highest level.

At United, he has always had other, more talented bodies around him and the pressure to perform, while still hugely daunting, seems bearable, even enjoyable to him. For England however, he is unable to carry the weight of a nation on his shoulders alone. To that end, he is not a player England should look to bail them out of a sinking ship again and again, he simply needs to be considered part of a team, a unit, a functioning group that work and play together.

England aren’t as good as Spain of ‘08 or ‘10, or even as good as Italy ‘06, but they can operate at a much higher level in international tournaments if they choose their attitude more carefully. Last summer, individuals were continually looked to. Eyes settled desperately on someone to do the footballing equivalent of kissing us on the forehead and applying a plaster after we’d fallen off our bike.

When it became abundantly clear that Rooney wasn’t at the races, we instinctively looked elsewhere for another neck to hang the by now rotting, featherless albatross around. Joe Cole. Gareth Barry. GARETH BARRY.

Spain are the most talented team in international football, but that’s not the sole reason they’re reigning European and World champions. They had bags of talent well before then but had always failed. The difference now is that they act, play and win (and lose) as a team. England owe it to themselves to at least attempt to do the same.

Rooney’s petulant lashing out shouldn’t be seen as ‘just our luck’, or ‘typical England’, it should be seen as an opportunity. The leg that kicked out at Montenegro’s Miodrag Dzudovic should be seen as an injection that rids the England football team of Talisman Syndrome forever.


Luke Moore is a founding member of The Football Ramble, and can be heard on the podcast every week. He also has contributed to ESPN, BBC 5 Live, BBC Radio London, Sky News and ITV.

Comments

Page 1 of 2  1 2 > 
Quality piece. I really liked the way you compared the current situation with Rooney to that of Raul and the way Lippi integrated Totti in without the attitude. The unfortunate thing is that the vast majority will continue with the view that it is 'just our luck'!
by Andy Hunter on 14 October 2011 at 03:03 PM

Absolutely spot on. Let's hope Fabio reads this.
by Paul Riley on 14 October 2011 at 03:26 PM

One of the best blogs I've ever read. And spot on with your analysis. Paraguay have had the same issues, first when Jose Luis Chilavert retired, and then with what happened to Salvador Cabañas. Sadly, we still haven't formed a proper "team".
by Sergio Lahaye on 14 October 2011 at 04:34 PM

Sergio - Rupert Fryer made that point about Cabañas, and it's a tragic story. Are you Paraguayan? Are there any other comparisons to be made between the two teams?
by Lukey Moore on 14 October 2011 at 05:07 PM

Luke, really good piece. I agree with 90% of it and strongly disagree w/ other 10%. That being the idea of, well, transcending the talisman. If you look at Spain, they still very much relied on Villa in the must-win games in the World Cup. Before Villa, they relied on Torres (and still a bit of Villa).

If Italy had a Cavani, they'd use him. It's a tricky situation. You want to play beautifully, but at the same time if you can't manage to knock a few in you're forgotten in history. The US under Klinsmann is facing this very dilemma. US fans wait desperately for the day we have someone who we can truly rely on for goals. We miss Brian McBride. It's fair to hope that relying on Rooney is a last resort, but if that's not even an option in your arsenal then you're going to inevitably struggle.
by Eric Beard on 14 October 2011 at 05:23 PM

Ewing Theory
'A star athlete receives an inordinate amount of media attention and fan interest, and yet his teams never win anything substantial with him (other than maybe some early-round playoff series).
That same athlete leaves his team (either by injury, trade, graduation, free agency or retirement) -- and both the media and fans immediately write off the team for the following season.'
A theory made popular by the American sports writer Bill Simmons.
by David Guest on 14 October 2011 at 05:28 PM

Eric - Cheers for your comment. I feel I should be a bit more clear what I mean though in response to your point.

It's ok for a team to rely on a player for goals or inspiration, but it needs to be within a team dynamic. Can you seriously argue that Spain actually look to Villa and before that Torres IN REPLACEMENT for a coherent and consistent tactical approach? I've certainly not seen any evidence of that in their two tournament wins. England do this with Rooney regularly. Spain may hope that their strikers score, or pull something out of the bag for them, but that's fine as long as the fortunes or behaviour of that player doesn't become the overarching focus. There is a clear and obvious difference between Raul and the two players you've mentioned. Raul was captain, spiritual leader and head honcho in the dressing room. The weight of the nation was on his shoulders for the four years he was captain. I see a post-Raul Spain as a team of superstars without a superstar, if that makes sense. Key difference.

Cavani isn't a valid example of Talisman Syndrome either. My knowledge of Uruguayan society isn't the best, but Uruguay are a pretty well drilled tactical unit and also have players like Forlan and Suarez who have as big expectations on them as Edinson does. Happy to be proven wrong on that one though, as I've never even visited Uruguay.
by Lukey Moore on 14 October 2011 at 05:35 PM

I liked this, blaming the failings of a side on the absence of one player papers over a much larger crack. That being, that England haven't for a long time looked like a coherent side with a unified focus. England with Rooney is fine, as long as there is an actual gameplan, an idea as to how we are going to play.
by Do I not like that on 14 October 2011 at 06:14 PM

Great piece, Lukey!
by Bryon Whitley on 14 October 2011 at 06:57 PM

Great piece! Having such a talismanic figure in your side can often be a hinderance. Totti was used within a team ethic in 06 by Lippi, something many coaches at Roma have struggled with. Players will naturally look to pass to player of Rooneys calibre in a team often devoid of any unity.

As you said, for years Italy have relied on a special playmaker to drive the side forward, now we don't have that sublime number 10 anymore Prandelli has had to build a team with a lack of "reference points" as he puts it, i.e no Totti or Del Piero and no carthorse upfront (Luca Toni) instead choosing to play with the likes of Cassano and Rossi as the two strikers, which has worked well.

How do you think Capello will alter the side to cope without Rooney?
by Enzo Filocco on 14 October 2011 at 07:46 PM

Typically great stuff Lukey!

Lippi had the experience and guile to get Totti to play more for the team in 06, that and the fact he knew it was his last chance for international glory.

Italy perhaps suffered in 2002 with the expectations on the likes of Totti/Del Piero..2006 was such a shambles before a ball was even kicked no one expected anything, creating a siege mentalitity which Lippi harnessed in a tight knit group of players playing for each other.
by Enzo Filocco on 14 October 2011 at 07:57 PM

GARETH BARRY. amen you wonderfully nordic looking man!
by Maxim on 14 October 2011 at 08:16 PM

Very good stuff, Spain & Italy are great comparisons but it is interesting to look to South America - like Sergio says it happened with Paraguay, it is happening with Argentina now and Messi, you can see it is going to start in Brazil with Neymar and who are Copa America champions, Uruguay with a cracking team, Suarez, Cavani & Forlan are treated as equals.
by Ralph Hannah on 14 October 2011 at 11:02 PM

Really good piece, Mr. Moore. I agree with your point and think we Americans have the same problem. We're still relying on Alexi Lalas far too much.
by Rich Cordero on 15 October 2011 at 04:05 AM

What a great article. It seems like common sense to all of us looking in. If only Fabio would subscribe to the Ramble, we'd all be saved.
by Jonny Sinclair on 15 October 2011 at 04:32 AM

Weird how these teams were able to drop these players like Raul and Totti and still be successful. It's almost like they had a plethora of talent in reserve and that these players were, relatively, on the wain.
Ship Rooney out I say. After all just like Spain had Torres and Villa, England have got Welbeck and Defoe. Those two will definitely do better than Rooney.
by KWolf on 15 October 2011 at 04:51 PM

I've been making this point for some time but no-where near as comprehensively or as articulately. Add into the whole equation the fear the players so obviously play with when representing England (fear of negative media???... possibly) that nurtures the 'knock it to the talisman and see what he can do' approach and I think you get somewhere close to the crux of the issue.
Post 'turnip head' Taylor etc...how can we get them to take a chance on the pitch and have self belief?
great piece
by Alan Bradford on 15 October 2011 at 08:26 PM

it was great that you mentioned joe cole, now that he is flying at LOSC perhaps he can finally be the man to lead us to glory?
by alexspeaker on 16 October 2011 at 08:37 PM

Very true.
by Oli Mercer on 17 October 2011 at 12:25 AM

I think we need an English Manager, Harry Redknapp would be the ideal choice and I think he'll know how to handle the british public and press.

For all the great qualities of Fabio, he just doesn't understand English culture and it's ment no one in england really care one bit about him.
by Simon on 17 October 2011 at 10:56 AM

Page 1 of 2  1 2 > 
Name:
Email:
Comment:
Prove you're not a bot:
What nationality is the original Ronaldo?

Remember my details

Latest on the site

Most popular on the site

The Ramble club shop

Support The Ramble and visit the shop to buy a unique t-shirt or two. In men and women's sizes.

Football Ramble t-shirt Football Ramble t-shirt Football Ramble t-shirt Football Ramble t-shirt Football Ramble t-shirt Football Ramble t-shirt

Social media

The Football Ramble on Twitter The Football Ramble on Facebook The Football Ramble on Mixcloud